Thursday, May 28, 2009

DOUBT

Director: John Patrick Shanley
Stars: Meryl Steep, Philip Seymour Hoffman, Amy Adams, Viola Davis
Year: 2008
Rating: PG-13

For anyone out there who still has any, uhh, "doubt" (sorry) about whether Meryl Streep is, indeed, the finest living actress around today - just put this film up against her performance in Mamma Mia! from the same year, and try to find another performer today who could have pulled off both such polar-opposite roles the way she did. Streep brings such passion, conviction, and immense talent to every character she takes on ... and never has that been more evident than in the role of Sister Aloysius Beauvier, a bitter and judgemental nun who runs her parish school in 1964 New York with an iron hand and a sharp tongue, delighting in terrorizing her students in order to keep them in line.

Very strong, charismatic performances are what make the film, and indeed Philip Seymour Hoffman's portrayal of Father Brendan Flynn goes head-to-head against Streep's ferocity, when Sister Aloysius learns from a young, teaching nun taken under her wing - Sister James (Amy Adams) - that she has seen Father Flynn engaging in some unusual behavior with a young Black male student at the school. Said behavior, as described by Sister James, could have any one of a dozen possible (and totally innocent) explanations - but in Sister Aloysius' twisted, sour mind only one explanation exists, and she becomes determined to find not so much the truth of what happened ... but her truth of what happened. Pecking away at the situation like a buzzard tearing flesh from a dead carcass, Sister not only slowly chips away at Father Flynn's character, background and motives - she also manages to ferment that same doubt in everyone and everything she touches, slowly making even the viewer unsure of Father Flynn's true role in the matter. Is the bottom line that Sister doesn't like Father Flynn's more progressive, forward-thinking attitudes regarding the Catholic church, and therefore just wants him out? Or does she really have the school and young man's interests at heart, wanting only to do the right thing and see a monster unmasked?

Based on the 2005 Pulitzer Prize-winning play, Doubt is a great mind game with the potential to make viewers question the courage of their own convictions more than once during the film. The four leads - Streep, Hoffman, Adams and Davis - give stellar performances that keep the film engrossing and viewers guessing ... though, in the end, don't necessarily expect a hard and fast resolution. Indeed, five different people watching this film could come to five different conclusions about the story (and characters) in it -then spend hours at dinner afterward, debating why they feel the way they do. That's the brilliance of the film; its ability to show you just how fragile your strongest beliefs can be when held up to the light of truth ... or how easily skewered they can become, when seen through corrupted eyes. **** - Reel Awesome

Monday, May 25, 2009

THE SECRETS

Director: Avi Nesher
Stars: Ania Bukstein, Michal Shtamler, Fanny Ardant, Adir Miller, Seffy Rivlin
Year: 2007
Rating: R
(in Hebrew and French w/English subtitles)

A film that seems to move forward on sure footing even as when you're not sure exactly what direction its taking, The Secrets is - at its center (I THINK) - a story about women's roles in Orthodox Israeli society today that, part-way through, segues into a tearjerker/love story with a smarmy, unreal ending that may leave viewers unsatisfied.

Ania Bukstein stars as Naomi, the beautiful, brainy daughter of a traditional Orthodox rabbi who has been studying Jewish law and tradition all of her life - even as she seeks, in time, to affect change in the way her own faith perceives women and their roles in the Jewish faith (her goal is to become the first female Orthodox rabbi). When Naomi's father wishes to marry her off to a strictly old-world student of his, she instead talks him into sending her to an all-girl seminary in Safed, to pursue her religious studies. Soon Naomi arrives at the school, where she meets her three roommates - one, in particular, being the chain-smoking, ill-tempered Michelle (Michal Shtamler) from Paris.

Naomi takes an instant dislike to Michelle, but soon is forced to set her feelings aside when the two girls are put in charge of taking food to a very ill Parisian lady staying nearby (Fanny Ardant, who brings the film its spark) - a woman with a scandalous, secret past that no one will discuss ... making the girls, of course, even more curious about her.

The woman finally reveals her past to the girls, but only because she wants them to help her find salvation for what she's done before she dies. Naomi is reluctant to help, knowing that doing so could get her in disastrous trouble, while Michelle of course is ready to jump in and do whatever it takes to make sure this lady dies cleansed of her sins. As Anouk (Ardant) becomes more ill and Naomi fights against time to find the correct rituals to see the woman off properly, a subplot begins that also finds Naomi and Michelle growing more and more attracted to each other physically - only adding to the risks they take as Anouk's time grows ever shorter.

The Secrets isn't a bad film - it's well-made, well-acted, and downright intriguing in places - yet somehow it unravels somewhat through the last third, as if it's still trying to decide just what kind of film it wants to be. The performances of the three leads are pretty solid, making it easy to get caught up in the characters - but what feels like an "important" film in the beginning turns into little more than a soap operatic love story with a too-neat, too-unrealistic (and slightly annoying) ending that ties everything up in a pretty (and conventional) bow that may have the echo of "I sat through all of this, for this?" running through your mind. ** - Reel Mediocre

MILK

Director: Gus Van Sant
Stars: Sean Penn, James Franco, Josh Brolin, Emile Hirsch, Diego Luna, Alison Pill, Joseph Cross, Lucas Grabeel, Victor Garber
Year: 2008
Rating: R

All the hype is true: Milk is an authentic, moving, and very humane film, beautifully written by Dustin Lance Black and skillfully directed by Gus Van Sant ... the tentpole for which lands on the shoulders of Sean Penn and Josh Brolin, who both turn in Oscar-worthy performances. The cast of Milk, in fact, is a huge reason the films works - is engaging and riveting from beginning to end. James Franco, Emile Hirsch, Diego Luna, Alison Pill, Joseph Cross, and even High School Musical alum Lucas Grabeel - all are at the top of their game here, each only adding to the heartbeat that gives this biopic its soul.

Real news footage, interspersed throughout, helps to give the film its 1970's feel as we first meet Harvey Milk (Penn) on his fortieth birthday. He finds a new boyfriend, Scott (James Franco), to celebrate with, and talks Scott into coming along with him when he moves to San Francisco to seek a new life. Once in the city, Milk learns that his new home is both the haven and hell for the GLBT community, and strives to make a change by speaking out for the rights of people who are "different" - but no less deserving of respect and their right to live and love. There are many in San Francisco who disagree with Harvey Milk, of course - and even in this film, set over thirty years ago, its chilling to see and hear some of the same homophobic slurs used even to this day - but soon Milk becomes somewhat of a local celebrity ... and becomes more and more of a threat to conservatives and right-wing Christians and Anita Bryant alike, as his popularity in the community only grows.

As Harvey fights the fight, gaining in supporters and strength, all the anti-gay hostility pointed against him can be summed up in the paranoid mind of Dan White (Brolin), a fellow politico who sees Milk as his biggest threat, both professionally and (in time) personally. As White sees Milk's message getting more and more popular in his city - as the GLBT community takes to the streets in support of its hero, an icon for change and basic human rights - its White who begins to unravel, deciding on a course of action that, in the end, only made Milk and his message that much more relevant.

It can't be said enough how human and well-acted this film is, from everyone involved in the cast. Like individual pieces of a puzzle only working with each other to create the total, perfect picture, each performance is first-rate and riveting to watch. In particular, James Franco's performance is so subtly layered, so really and sympathetic and compelling, you can see why Harvey Milk fell in love with Scott after just one night.

A terrific film with Penn (turning in a careful, understated and truly chameleon-like performance - maybe the best of his career) at its center, Milk is one of those films that should be seen by everyone - and should be studied in acting classes for caliber of its talent. Not one frame is wasted of one of the top-ten films released in 2009, a "must-have" for the DVD library of anyone who calls themselves a lover of film. ****1/2 - Reel Awesome-Reel Must-See

Sunday, May 24, 2009

THE GRUDGE 3

Director: Toby Wilkins
Stars: Gil McKinney, Johanna Braddy, Matthew Knight, Emi Ikehata, Shawnee Smith, Beau Mirchoff
Year: 2009
Rating: R

Well, you sort of know you're in trouble with a sequel when it's released directly to DVD. Worse, when most of the original cast members and even the original director didn't come back for the latest installment.

That said, The Grudge 3 - the direct-to-DVD release of the third installment in the HIGHLY Americanized version of a popular Japanese horror film series - could have been a lot worse. Sadly, it also could have been infinitely better.

The film opens with the sole surviving member from the Chicago apartment house setting from part two - Jake (Matthew Knight). Jake's entire family was killed off in the second installment - all except his stepmother, who police think did the murders but was really possessed by the ghost of Kayako - and the shock has left the young boy so unhinged and in fear of his life (he knows the supernatural is at work, here), he's been confined to a padded cell by Dr. Sullivan (Shawnee Smith of the ever-growing Saw franchise), the psychiatrist attached to his case. Jake has been put away for his own good, to alleviate his fears - but the kid saw too much of what's going on to believe he's anywhere near safe, and begs to be released ... a wish Dr. Sullivan doesn't grant, much to her regret early on in the film.

Meanwhile, back at the apartment house, the deaths (and weird occurrences in general) have tenants moving out left and right - which leaves the building's manager, Max (Gil McKinney, doing the best he can here, with what he's given to work with, script-wise), stressing over losing his job. His younger sister Lisa (Johanna Braddy), about to move to New York City with her boyfriend (Beau Mirchoff), he's not so worried about ... but the parent-less siblings also have a young sister named Rose, and Rose has some severe breathing/health problems. Max feels Rose is his responsibility, and he can't let anything jeopardize that.

Add into the mix Naoko (Emi Ikehata) - a young, somewhat mysterious Japanese woman who, we learn early on, may hold the key to curing the curse for good - and what's supposed to unfold is a suspenseful and scary thriller that pits the long Japanese woman against one funky pair of mother-son ghosts ... ghosts who are slowly devouring anyone and everyone in the apartment building touched by their rage.

Anyway, that's what is supposed to unfold. But in reality, the suspense is barely suspenseful - and the death scenes are all shot either too dark or too fast, and with (often, but not always) cheesy special effects; it's as if the budget just wasn't there for elaborate gross out-ery (with the possible exception of one fairly interesting sequence featuring Marina Sirtis from "Star Trek: The Next Generation," who plays Rose's babysitter), so the director just used quick cuts and dark lighting to cover the cheese. Worse still, the actors playing both ghosts - the stair-crawling Kayoko, and her cat-boy son Toshio - are not the same as in the first two films, and it shows; hell, the boy playing Toshio, who's supposed to be 8-10 years old, looks at least fifteen in part three - when first seen, seated and with his legs folded into his chest on a stairwell, it's almost laughable how wrong the actor is for the part. Even the makeup on both ghosts is just plain silly - both actors look like they've been dipped in flour, and you can even spot Kayako actually wearing a wife beater (white tanktop) in one "death scene."

Characters doing things that don't make sense, plot logic is thrown out the window in several places, and the death scenes - both in originality and style - pale in comparison to the first two films in this American series (I still say if you want the best versions, see the Japanese originals). Even the ending - which Gil McKinney's performance barely manages to hold together - is still, by the time the credits roll, both ambiguous and silly ... setting up the possibility for a part four that really doesn't need to be made.

Not a horrible film - but surely not a good one. Probably for completist fans of the series only, who need to see it just because they've seen the others and want to know how it all plays out. Other than that - only silly, low budget chills (at best) await. ** - Reel Mediocre