Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Trailer: COWBOYS & ALIENS

THE TRAP

Director: Howard Bretherton
Stars: Sidney Toler, Victor Sen Yung, Mantan Moreland, Anne Nagel, Tanis Chandler, Kirk Alyn
Year: 1946
Rating: N/R

When Monogram picked up the Charlie Chan film series from Twentieth Century-Fox, the quality of the films - which had always been entertaining and just a lot of fun to watch - seriously dipped from low-budget to practically no-budget territory. Sidney Toler, having taken over the role years before after the death of Warner Oland, gave Charlie Chan a warmth and humor the character had not had on-screen before. Toler was pretty much my favorite Chan, and this was the last film he made as the character, before his death in 1947 from cancer. Sadly, it's not a fitting tribute to the fine character actor, as The Trap features poor acting, poor writing, and a weary Sidney Toler who looks ill here, and isn't even introduced into the film until twenty minutes in - which, considering the running time of The Trap is just over sixty minutes, is pretty significant.

The plot, such as it is, revolves around a theatrical troupe - mostly female - who rent a beach house in Malibu for some well-deserved time off. The female performers are headed by the vain, bossy Marcia (Anne Nagel), who knows enough dirt on the other girls, she pretty much gets away with everything, even though the others hate her. The very day they move into the beach house, Marcia blackmails a young ingenue named Lois into stealing some incrimination letters from the trunk of another girl, and during the theft Lois is strangled to death by an unknown assailant. A state trooper who had pulled the troop over earlier in the film (Kirk Alyn) starts the investigation, but it's one of the women - a young Chinese girl named San Toy - who calls Jimmy Chan (Victor Sen Yung) for help, and soon Jimmy's father, the great detective Charlie Chan, is on the case ... along with his bumbling chauffeur Birmingham, played with humor and to great "yessir, boss, yessir!" stereotype by Mantan Moreland. At first Charlie's mission seems to be to find Marcia - who has gone missing since the murder, and is presumed to be the killer - but when Marcia's body washes up on shore the next morning, also strangled, it's up to Charlie Chan to figure out the motives and means ... and the identity of a dangerous killer.

While the film is not a total waste - especially for Chan aficionados - there is not enough here to make the film worthy of more than maybe a single viewing. Most of the cast truly hams it up for the camera, and the cast of characters leans toward run-of-the-mill stereotypes you will find in any murder mystery/thriller, right down to the sinister housekeeper/caretaker of the beach house, a C-movie version of Mrs. Danvers from Rebecca who goes around quoting about drink being the root of all evil. The playful, humorous banter between Victor Sen Yung and Toler, which was one of the best reasons to watch the series (especially when it was with Twentieth Century-Fox) is almost non-existent, the plot is both convoluted and fairly laughable, with lots of screaming from the girls and an ending that's a bit boring to say the least.

Sad that this was Toler's last film - but good that he left a legacy of great work behind, Chan and otherwise, as a terrific character actor; one who deserved better than this for his final bow. ** - Reel Mediocre